Beautiful woman thinking laptop on cafe table with coffee and croissant

11 Reasons a Woman Might Decide to Date Someone Considered Below Their League

This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Our choices in companionship can often be perplexing to others, as everyone possesses an internal matchmaker whose preferences may not align with those of others. The intricacies of dating are intricate and diverse, with one intriguing facet frequently taking center stage: the reasons why some women opt to date men perceived as “below their league.”

People on an online platform discussed why this may be so.

1. It’s About Personality

laughing woman on blue background
Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

Some people base the ‘out-of-league’ judgment mostly on looks, and it is often baffling when one partner is a looker while the other is, well, not so much. Many people, however, go for personality and will be attracted to someone for their personality rather than their looks (at least long-term).

One user says, “Personality is pretty much everything in a relationship, for men and women. We might be attracted to people physically when we first meet, but personality and compatibility take over soon after.”

2. They’re With Them Temporarily

strange woman with blue hair tongue out eccentric
Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

Someone says that sometimes, a person is with another person because they need someone to hold the fort until THE ONE arrives. Some women choose to get a “boy toy” for fun, and the two will look like a mismatch to outsiders.

One user shares, “The person who is bringing more to the relationship just wants a boy/girl toy. Someone to have fun with and then kick them out of their life when someone better comes along. [It] could be, it’s just after ending a long-term relationship, and they are not ready to sleep in an empty/cold bed.”

3. Emotional Stability

nervous embarrassed confused shocked woman
Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

People who may have experienced trauma in their lives, especially one that involved loved ones leaving, will want to be with people who are least likely to leave. They’re looking for emotional stability and independence, someone who considers it a privilege to be with them.

They say, “A high IQ, high achieving woman does not need to date the loser who is unemployed and lives with his mom. But, that guy will be so thrilled to get attention, he will come over, day or night, and just sit there while she talks about what she is going through.” Maybe?

4. They Just Like Them

laughing couple
Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

Sometimes, there really is no hidden agenda; the woman dating the man “below” their league plainly likes them.

Someone says, “If she likes him enough to date him, he’s not “beneath her potential,” because she likes him. Whether you find him attractive is irrelevant unless you also want to date him.” SO true.

5. Values and Beliefs

happy couple in love drinking at a bar date night
Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

While someone else’s relationship may be raising more questions than answers, we may stop to consider that their value systems are different from ours.

What some may consider ‘out-of-league’ may be non-issues for others.

6. They Don’t Think About “Dating Potential”

Brave woman as superhero
Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

Attraction is rarely planned, and people often get attracted to someone without thinking much about whether or not this person meets the criteria for being with them.

One user gives an example, “I have never in my life thought, “Well, I like Mary, but she’s possibly beneath my dating potential. Maybe I should date Joan instead…”

7. Beauty is in the Beholder’s Eyes

Woman Rejecting To Kiss man On Unsuccessful Date Walking Outside
Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

Sometimes, the verdict on dating someone “beneath” is not entirely supported by facts. Physical attraction and beauty are subjective; what one person may consider ugly maybe someone else’s beauty standards.

A user contributes, “Everyone is beautiful to somebody, just because you don’t find the person attractive doesn’t mean the person in question doesn’t.”

8. Too Handsome Equals Untrustworthy

laughing man on white background
Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

If looks are used to measure the inequality in the relationship, then some people argue that some women view very handsome men as untrustworthy.

They will, therefore, choose to be with someone with average looks even if they themselves are drop-dead gorgeous, as it’s assumed (even if subconsciously) that the less handsome man is trustworthy.

A user shares, “I don’t have to look like Brad Pitt, and in fact, she [the gorgeous wife] has told me it’s better that I don’t because men who are too handsome are not trustworthy; they have too much temptation, and it goes to their heads, and they always stray.”

9. They’re Looking For Deeper Qualities

Laughing woman in grey background
Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

While matching looks and financial muscle may make a couple look well-matched, women are now looking for more qualities in the men they date. This means a woman will choose better character quality any day over better looks.

A contributor says, “My wife is gorgeous. I would not consider myself particularly attractive. She told me that she’s glad we met when she was in her late 30s, because at an earlier age she would not have valued the qualities I brought: financial responsibility, stability, humor, emotional availability, reliability, solid co-parenting, and a firm commitment to see to her needs.” Now, that sounds sexy to a woman ready to settle down!

10. Dating is Not a Game

proud blond hero man with happy expression
Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

Some people view dating and relationships as a game in which they must win the jackpot. For others, this doesn’t come into play; they love whom they love without any strings attached or boxes ticked.

Someone says, “For some people, dating is a game with scores and ranks. For others, it isn’t.”

11. Same Interests

Happy smiling couple
Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

Many women prefer having someone with whom they share the same interests, as opposed to the acceptable societal standards.

Someone says, “My husband and I like the looks on people’s faces when they see us together. I’m tall, he’s short. I’m of Irish descent, he’s Han Chinese. I’m fit and curvy, he’s gained some weight. I’m really fashionable and he likes gym shorts and sweatshirts. However, we both went to the same college, are both highly intelligent and enjoy most of the same hobbies. None of that shows on the outside. But that’s all that matters to us. I love him to pieces.”


Intense Satisfaction: 25 Daily Occurrences That Feel Oh-So-Good

happy smiling woman
Photo Credit:

For each of us, certain activities can give us a sense of relief or pleasure (or both)- and they have nothing to do with being intimate. Instead, these everyday things are surprisingly toe-curling. People share their favorites in an online forum, ranging from relatable to interesting and funny.

Intense Satisfaction: 25 Daily Occurrences That Feel Oh-So-Good

12 Crazy Exes That Have People Thanking Their Lucky Stars They Got Out

crazy man shocked surprised confused
Photo Credit:

The conclusion of a relationship frequently leaves a wake of broken hearts, tears, and lasting remorse. In the aftermath, it’s customary to ponder what could have been altered to salvage the situation. Occasionally, we look back and discover gratitude for having moved forward, even wondering why we didn’t make that choice earlier.

12 Crazy Exes That Have People Thanking Their Lucky Stars They Got Out

12 Signs Your Marriage Will Last Even the Hardest of Times

happy couple smiling with heart
Photo Credit:

In a culture where skepticism and pessimism often surround the idea of long-lasting marriages, many contend that maintaining a successful union is an almost insurmountable challenge, given the inherent difficulties of married life.

12 Signs Your Marriage Will Last Even the Hardest of Times

11 Creative Ways to Make Time for Your Partner When You Have Kids

happy couple fist bump red
Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

How do you make time for each other when some little hands, feet and stuffed noses constantly need you?

11 Creative Ways to Make Time for Your Partner When You Have Kids

Essential Christmas Gift Ideas For Busy Moms

christmas gift in the hands
Photo Credit: Deposit Photos.

I love finding the perfect gifts for all of my mom’s friends – something they’ll really appreciate? But true to all moms in the world, we seem to have a really hard time asking for what we want for Christmas.

Essential Christmas Gift Ideas For Busy Moms

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *